Etsy or Shopify? It's one of the most common questions new sellers ask โ and the answer isn't one or the other. It's understanding what each platform does well, and which one fits where you are right now.
The 30-second summary
| Etsy | Shopify | |
|---|---|---|
| Built-in audience | โ 92 million buyers | โ You build your own |
| Monthly fee | Free to open | $29-299/month |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% + payment fees | 0-2% + payment fees |
| Control | Limited | Full |
| Setup time | 1-2 hours | 1-2 days |
| Best for beginners | โ Yes | โ Steeper curve |
| Best for scaling | Limited | โ Yes |
The case for Etsy
You get 92 million buyers from day one
This is Etsy's superpower. When you publish a listing on Etsy, you're immediately visible to millions of people actively searching for products like yours. You don't need to run ads, build a following, or do any marketing to get your first sales.
On Shopify, you start with zero customers. You have to bring them all yourself โ through ads, SEO, social media, or other channels. That costs money, time, and expertise.
Lower upfront costs
Opening an Etsy shop costs $0. You pay $0.20 per listing and a 6.5% transaction fee only when you sell. If you make no sales, you pay almost nothing.
Shopify costs $29-299/month regardless of sales. You're paying before you've validated your product.
Trusted brand name
Buyers already trust Etsy. The checkout process is familiar, secure, and supported. As a new seller, borrowing Etsy's brand credibility converts better than asking strangers to enter their credit card on an unfamiliar Shopify domain.
SEO visibility
Etsy's domain has enormous SEO authority. A well-optimized Etsy listing can rank on Google faster than most new Shopify stores.
The case for Shopify
You own the customer relationship
On Etsy, you never get the buyer's email address (unless they opt in). You can't remarket to them, email them about new products, or build a loyal customer base you control.
On Shopify, every customer is yours. You capture their email at checkout. You can email them anytime. This compounds dramatically over time.
Lower percentage fees at scale
Etsy takes 6.5% + payment fees (~9-10% total) on every sale. Shopify takes 0-2% (depending on plan) + payment fees (~3%).
At $10,000/month in sales:
- Etsy fees: ~$1,000
- Shopify fees: ~$400 (including monthly plan)
At scale, Shopify becomes cheaper despite the monthly fee.
Full customization
Shopify lets you build exactly the brand experience you want โ custom domain, custom design, custom checkout, upsells, loyalty programs, subscription products. Etsy shops all look similar.
No risk of account suspension
Etsy can suspend your account at any time โ for policy violations, copyright issues, or even algorithmically by mistake. On Shopify, you own your store.
The fees compared in detail
| Fee type | Etsy | Shopify Basic |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly fee | $0 | $29 |
| Listing fee | $0.20/item | $0 |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% | 2% |
| Payment processing | ~3% + $0.25 | 2.9% + $0.30 |
| Offsite Ads (over $10K/yr) | 12% on those sales | N/A |
| Total on $100 sale | ~$10.45 | ~$6.20 (+$29/mo) |
Who should use Etsy
- Complete beginners with no existing audience
- Testing a product before investing in a full store
- Handmade sellers โ Etsy's buyer base specifically seeks handmade
- Low volume sellers who can't justify $29/month
- Anyone who hates marketing โ Etsy brings the traffic
Who should use Shopify
- Sellers doing $5,000+/month who want lower fees
- Anyone building a real brand with repeat customers
- Sellers with an existing audience (Instagram, TikTok, email list)
- Businesses selling outside of handmade (dropshipping, wholesale)
- Anyone wanting full control over their customer data
The honest answer: use both
The most successful e-commerce businesses don't choose โ they run both.
Use Etsy to find your winning products (the ones that actually sell), build your first reviews, and generate initial cash flow. Then open a Shopify store once you have proof of concept, and start driving traffic to your own domain.
Most top Etsy sellers also have a Shopify store. They use Etsy as a traffic engine and Shopify as their customer ownership and retention system.
Find your own break-even point
The fee comparison above uses example figures. Your own numbers decide the answer, so work it out for your shop before choosing. Shopify plan prices and card rates change, so check the current pricing page before you plug them in.
- Estimate your monthly sales and average order value.
- Work out your Etsy fees: 6.5% transaction fee on each order total, including shipping, plus payment processing (3% + $0.25 per order in the US), plus $0.20 per listing.
- Work out the Shopify equivalent: the monthly plan, card processing, and any apps you would need to pay for.
- Add the cost of bringing your own traffic to Shopify. On Etsy, search brings visitors for free; on your own store, ads, content and time replace that.
Example: 50 orders a month at $30 is $1,500 in sales. Etsy's transaction fee is $97.50 and US payment processing is about $57.50. If you would need to spend $150 a month on ads to get the same 50 orders on Shopify, Etsy is the cheaper option at that size. The Etsy profit calculator helps you see what you keep across several products.
Signs you are ready to add your own store
Opening a second channel too early splits your time just when your Etsy shop needs it. Wait until most of these are true:
- You have products that sell steadily every month, not just one lucky listing.
- Some buyers order from you more than once.
- You already have an audience outside Etsy, such as an email list or an active social account.
- You can produce and ship your current orders without falling behind.
If only one or two apply, put the effort into your Etsy listings first. Guides like scaling an Etsy shop cover what to fix before you expand.
Keep both shops consistent
If you do run both, keep prices and stock in sync so neither store promises something you cannot deliver. Update both whenever you change a price, and check stock counts weekly if an item sells on both channels.
Pack an insert card with each Etsy order that mentions your website, but keep it to a simple thank-you and your store address rather than pushing buyers to leave Etsy.
Quick answers
At what point is Shopify cheaper than Etsy?
It depends on your sales volume and how much you would spend on ads to bring traffic to your own store. Compare Etsy's fees with Shopify's monthly plan, card processing, apps and marketing costs at your current sales level.
Can I sell the same products on Etsy and Shopify?
Yes, many sellers list the same products on both. Keep prices and stock counts in sync so you never sell an item on one store that is already sold out on the other.
Whether you start on Etsy or both platforms, ListifyAI creates SEO-optimized Etsy listings from one product photo in 30 seconds. Try free with 20 credits.
๐ Start with Etsy today
ListifyAI makes writing Etsy listings fast โ title, 13 tags, description in 30 seconds. Free trial available.
Try ListifyAI free โ